Beyond the Résumé: A Case Study of How a Class of 2025 Student’s Focus and Leadership Led to Admission at a Top Liberal Arts College

The college admissions process can often feel like a race to accumulate achievements, but the most compelling applications go beyond a list of activities. Colleges seek students who demonstrate depth, commitment, and a clear sense of purpose.



This case study follows a Class of 2025 student we worked with—a methodical thinker with a strong academic foundation, deep leadership in marching band and DECA, and a focused interest in business. Rather than stretching themselves thin across numerous activities, this student dedicated their time to a few key commitments, making a lasting impact through leadership and mentorship. By staying true to their interests, challenging themselves academically, and reflecting deeply on their experiences, they built an application that stood out to admissions officers at a highly competitive liberal arts college with a strong business program.

A Structured, Business-Oriented Student

From the start, this student stood out as a thoughtful, highly structured individual with a clear interest in business. Ranked in the top 7–8% of their class, they balanced academic rigor with long-term dedication to two core extracurriculars: marching band and DECA. Their approach wasn’t about accumulating activities—it was about making a meaningful impact in the areas that mattered most.


Key Strengths in Their Application

Strong Leadership and Extracurricular Involvement

This student demonstrated a deep commitment to a few high-impact activities, showcasing discipline, leadership, and business acumen.

  • Marching Band:
  • Dedicated significant time to a highly competitive program, demonstrating discipline and perseverance.
  • Earned multiple individual competition awards, highlighting both technical skill and performance excellence.
  • Senior year: Secured a top leadership position, mentoring younger members and leading structured routines.
  • DECA (Distributive Education Clubs of America):
  • Competed in business case competitions, refining problem-solving and presentation skills.
  • Took on a leadership role within their DECA chapter, further reinforcing their interest in business and mentorship.
  • Gained hands-on experience in marketing, finance, and management—key areas of academic focus.
  • Tutoring and Community Service:
  • Started tutoring math in 9th grade and continued throughout high school.
  • By junior year, trained and mentored new tutors, demonstrating leadership through service.
  • Helped peers develop confidence in math, strengthening their own communication and adaptability skills.


Academic Depth and Business Exploration

This student’s academic choices reflected a genuine curiosity about business and finance.

  • Business-Focused Coursework:
  • Took multiple business classes in high school, reinforcing their long-term interest in the field.
  • Highlighted these courses on their résumé to demonstrate early academic preparation.
  • College-Level Coursework and Internship:
  • Completed a college-level accounting course over the summer, proving readiness for advanced study.
  • Secured an accounting internship, where they worked on real projects and applied classroom knowledge to a professional setting.
  • While the internship was facilitated through a family connection, they fully engaged in the experience and reflected meaningfully on what they learned.


Long-Term Commitment and Leadership Development

Instead of spreading themselves across numerous activities, this student focused on making a significant impact in a few key areas.

  • Marching Band: Leadership in a structured, team-driven environment.
  • DECA: Business competitions, problem-solving, and mentorship.
  • Tutoring: A sustained commitment to service and leadership.

This focused approach helped their application stand out by showing depth, consistency, and growth over time.


Thoughtful Reflection and a Self-Driven Approach

What set this student apart wasn’t just their activities—it was their ability to articulate how each experience shaped their skills and ambitions.

  • Marching Band: Taught discipline, teamwork, and leadership under pressure.
  • DECA: Strengthened strategic thinking, business problem-solving, and public speaking.
  • Internship: Provided firsthand experience in finance and solidified interest in a business-related major.
  • Tutoring: Developed patience, adaptability, and the ability to explain complex concepts clearly.

Rather than just listing accomplishments, they demonstrated introspection and personal growth, qualities that resonate with admissions officers.


The Outcome

This student’s structured, business-focused application made a lasting impression. They were admitted early to a highly selective liberal arts college known for its strong business program. Their success came from:

  • Excelling academically and demonstrating readiness for advanced coursework.
  • Pursuing business consistently through classes, DECA, and an internship.
  • Taking on leadership roles in extracurriculars and service-oriented activities.
  • Effectively reflecting on their experiences in essays, connecting their work to personal and intellectual growth.



Key Takeaways for Future Applicants

  1. Depth matters more than breadth. Colleges value sustained commitment and leadership in a few key areas over a long list of activities.
  2. A clear academic focus strengthens an application. This student’s interest in business was demonstrated across coursework, extracurriculars, and real-world experiences.
  3. Structured thinking and leadership stand out. Their ability to take on leadership roles in highly disciplined environments like marching band and DECA set them apart.
  4. Reflection is key. More than just listing achievements, they articulated how each experience contributed to their academic and personal growth.
  5. Authenticity makes an impact. They didn’t try to fit into a mold—they leaned into what genuinely excited them and built an application around their strengths.

This case study reinforces that the most compelling applications aren’t about doing everything—they’re about doing what matters most with intention, depth, and purpose.



Share by: